Background: The aging population in the Global North is associated with an increased prevalence of multiple chronic diseases that would benefit from integrated palliative care. In this context, it is vital to consider the effectiveness of health care systems’ response to the needs of the older population residing in rural areas, including access to palliative care services. Understanding palliative care program availability and palliative care system characteristics is important in creating useful health interventions in rural areas.
Objective: This study aims to provide an international view on palliative care in rural areas. A study exploring palliative care services offered in Southern Minnesota will be carried out, building on a previous study conducted in Osona, Spain. Findings from both studies will be compared, providing insights into the strengths of each system and identifying areas for growth.
Methods: This study will be performed using qualitative case study methodology. Using a similar methodology to the one used in the Spanish study, palliative care services will be explored in a similarly sized rural area in Southern Minnesota. This will be accomplished by (1) reviewing available literature related to the Southern Minnesota palliative care system and (2) identifying key providers in this US palliative care system who will be invited to participate in semistructured interviews. The study participants will be asked about the gaps between ideal integrated palliative care system services and the existing complementary palliative care services, and the ethical issues and dilemmas that evolved during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Results: Following ethical approval for this protocol, data collection is anticipated to begin in spring or summer 2022 and is expected to take 6 months. Data collection will be followed by data analysis in fall 2022. Finally, the researchers plan to disseminate the findings in spring 2023.
Conclusions: Comparing 2 similarly sized but culturally different rural palliative care systems in Minnesota and Osona will provide insights into how integrated palliative care systems impact the older population and those with chronic illnesses. Study findings will contribute to enhanced patient care, organizational improvements, policy change, and an understanding of the impact of different health care system models.
International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): PRR1-10.2196/36037
An aging population in the Global North is associated with an increased prevalence of chronic diseases that will ultimately contribute to their death . Due to the population’s increasing life span and resultant aging, it is essential to consider how effectively health care systems, especially palliative care services, respond to patients with chronic illnesses [ - ].
The World Health Organization states that palliative care aims to improve quality of life for those patients living with life-limiting diseases, by reducing pain and proactively managing and treating symptoms associated with their disease processes . Historically, palliative care was limited to patients with cancer [ ] and was described as care for individuals with a life-threatening disease [ ]. With an aging population, palliative care systems evolved and are no longer limited to oncological or life-threatening diseases [ ]. Palliative care currently includes patients with multiple morbidities [ ] and individuals in need of quality-of-life–focused care due to frailty, advanced age [ ], or disabling conditions [ , ]. Thus, palliative care services are justified based on individual patients’ needs rather than specific diagnostic codes. The target patient for palliative care is an individual with a “palliative cluster” of symptoms or factors, including a life-threatening or life-limiting, chronic, or terminal condition, necessitating multidimensional needs.
Past health care models focused on disease-directed care in which the recognition of the terminal nature of a patient’s condition occurs late, resulting in delayed hospice and end-of-life care . However, the changes in managing chronic and life-limiting conditions to enhance the quality of life have resulted in a new model in which palliative care service is initiated at the time of diagnosis. In this model, the focus shifts toward symptom management rather than cure, and a transition to hospice care when a patient’s life expectancy is 6 months or less; during this time, the primary purpose of care is maximizing the patient’s quality of life [ ].
A challenge for health care systems is how to provide integrated care for patients with increasingly complex chronic conditions . Integrated care is a combination of multiple disciplines at different levels of care, focused on improving the quality of health care services [ ]. It also facilitates connections and cooperation between funding sources, organizations, and clinical services, with the purpose of offering efficient and high-quality care. As a result, integrated palliative care (IPC) provides coordinated services of care [ ].
For patients in Southern Minnesota, access to palliative and hospice care services can differ based on the type of insurance the patient has. For example, the national insurance for the older population, Medicare Part A, covers inpatient hospital stays, short-term stays at nursing facilities, and home care . Reimbursement for palliative care is not standardized as it is for hospice care [ , ]. In contrast, the Spanish health care system provides universal access to all residents. Instituto Nacional de la Salud (the government’s public health organization) provides health care services to all communities in the country [ ], and these services include palliative care for patients with chronic illnesses and terminal diseases.
In both countries, with aging populations, the main challenge for health care systems is to provide integrated care for patients with increasingly complex chronic conditions . IPC is an approach to improve services for patients with chronic illnesses and terminal diseases.
The COVID-19 pandemic can be a distinguishing marker between the period considered “normal” and the pandemic era, which brought many changes to society and health care delivery [, ]. The pandemic also impacted health care providers who were faced with ethical dilemmas such as determining resource allocation and the prioritization of patient care [ ], as well as end-of-life care decisions [ ]. Additional ethical concerns encountered by palliative care providers were autonomy in the patient and family decision-making processes [ ], the discontinuation of treatments and therapies [ ], and communicating with families and patients in a society that required social distancing and limiting factors such as face masks [ ].
When taking care of patients with chronic conditions, integrative and complementary care is often experienced as beneficial . The integrative health approach provides patients in need of palliative care with nonpharmacological strategies to manage pain and other nausea, depression, and anxiety symptoms [ ]. Examples include aromatherapy, acupuncture, massage, homeopathic practices, and cultural practices [ ]. In addition, palliative care in conjunction with complementary care can offer patients comfort during this phase of life [ ].
One way to see how care is being delivered to people with complex chronic conditions is through the analysis of reality; therefore, this study aims to first describe the Southern Minnesota palliative care system in the United States and then compare it to the palliative care system in Spain. To be able to carry out the general objective of the study, the following specific objectives will be developed:
- Describing the palliative care system in Southern Minnesota
- Comprehending the ethical dilemmas health care providers encounter while providing care in the Southern Minnesota palliative care system
- Identifying specific impacts resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic
- Assessing the complementary services offered by palliative care service providers in Southern Minnesota
- Identifying and comparing the commonalities and differences between this study in Southern Minnesota and the results found in a previous study from Osona, Spain
Design and Methods
This research will follow the same design and methods used in the study conducted in Osona, Spain (M Mondejar-Pont, PhD, unpublished data, November 2020). This study will use a qualitative methodology with a prospective, multiple embedded case study design as described by Yin . This design allows us to explore the embedded subunits of multiple cases to understand more about the case itself.
This study will describe the Southern Minnesota palliative care service and its essential integrated palliative care system elements, identify the ethical dilemmas experienced, and identify the complementary therapies offered. The results found in this study will then be compared to the results found in the initial study conducted in Osona, Spain. This comparison will aim to identify similarities, differences, and informative aspects that may benefit each system, while taking into consideration the contextual and cultural differences between the two.
Blue Earth, Nicollet, and Brown counties in Southern Minnesota were selected for this study based on similarities between these areas and the region in Spain that is the population of comparison. In addition, Blue Earth, Nicollet, and Brown Counties include the Mankato metropolitan area and the surrounding rural areas  that have significantly smaller populations and less access to health care services. These counties will be referred to as Southern Minnesota for ease of readability.
These 2 regions were selected since they have similar populations: Osona county has a population of 163,702 , and Southern Minnesota has a population of 125,912 [ ]. In these regions, the older population is represented with a similar proportion: 18% in Osona [ ] and 24% in Southern Minnesota [ ]. With a significant proportion of rural populations aging in place, access to palliative care service is imperative yet more challenging outside of larger urban areas [ ]. By comparing and contrasting two similarly sized regions with different health care systems and reimbursement models, this research will ultimately provide information that the palliative care systems in both regions can use to improve their practices.
Consistent with the study completed in Osona, Spain, this study will use a purposive sampling strategy including the following 2 types of participants who will be invited to take part in the study: (1) those who hold decision-making positions in organizations providing palliative care, including managers, coordinators, or lead administrators; and (2) professionals involved in the provision of palliative care, such as nurses, social workers, and physicians.
We anticipate interviewing up to 25 participants, similar to the study completed in Spain, representing a wide variety of roles within palliative care systems. Interviews will be analyzed using the direct content analysis approach explained further below, and the analysis will conclude once the research team determines that data saturation has been reached. The research team will determine that data saturation has been reached when no new additional information, new codes, or categories are possible to obtain. If data saturation is not reached after 25 interviews, interviews will continue until saturation is reached.
Initially, professionals in leadership positions will be interviewed about the palliative care system. The interviews with individuals in leadership positions aim to gain a holistic sense of the organization, communication, and coordination efforts at the macro level. These professionals, following a snowball strategy, will provide contact information of direct care providers. Direct care providers can give more detailed insights about the palliative care system at the micro level.
The study will be divided into the following 2 phases to respond to the study’s main goals:
- Phase 1 aims to identify a description of the palliative care system in Southern Minnesota through a search in the available documents and literature review.
- In Phase 2, the aim is to identify the integrated elements of palliative care systems; the ethical dilemmas encountered prior to, during, and in the current phase of the COVID-19 pandemic; and the complementary care offered. During this phase, key personnel and direct health care professionals will be interviewed individually by members of the research team. These semistructured interviews will take place via teleconferencing or phone. All interviews will be audio recorded ( includes the survey questions) to be later transcribed and analyzed. Finally, the results from this study of the Southern Minnesota palliative care system will be compared with the results found in the research completed in Osona, Spain.
Data Management and Analysis
Anonymous participant data will be stored in a protected database such as Microsoft Teams with a login function. The master database will be kept in a password-protected, university-issued computer.
Interviews will be audio recorded and transcribed verbatim. Transcriptions will be analyzed using deductive content analysis supported by the qualitative data analysis software NVivo (version 12; QSR International).
The deductive or directed content analysis approach uses previous research findings to examine the studies’ new data to identify similarities and differences and compare the same categories at different times and in other locations. Deductive content analysis has 3 main processes: data preparation, organization, and reporting. In the data preparation phase, a matrix of categories from existing theories is created and then compared to the emerging categories from the study’s data . In the organization phase, documents and interviews will be analyzed using deductive content analysis, and prior theoretical propositions will guide the initial coding process and formation of first categories. Then, new categories emerging from the data will be generated, and finally, links between initial and newly generated categories will be established and reported as results.
The research team members will individually review study findings, identifying themes, concepts, and case components; the research team will then meet to discuss results until consensus and data saturation are reached. Once themes, concepts, and case components have been identified for the Southern Minnesota palliative care system, they will be compared to those in Osona’s palliative care system. Similarities and differences will be used to identify system strengths and areas for growth.
Informed consent will be obtained to assure voluntary participation. Participants may withdraw at any time at their discretion. Therefore, we believe that the potential for risk in this study is minimal.
To minimize the burden of data collection on busy professionals, interviews will be limited to a maximum of 60 minutes. Interviews will be conducted by experienced researchers.
An application for ethical approval has been submitted to the Institutional Review Board of Minnesota State University, Mankato and is awaiting approval (1877595).
This study was initiated in August 2021, when the research team met and established its organization and the project goals. The Institutional Review Board application was submitted in April 2022, and further project planning has been undertaken during spring 2022. Results are pending ethical review and data collection, which will take place in spring and summer 2022, followed by data analysis in fall 2022. Dissemination of results and development of various study reports will be anticipated after data analysis is completed in 2023.
Anticipated results for this study are expected to be consistent with those found in the foundational study completed in Osona, Spain. In that study, major themes included a need for improved collaboration, continuity of care, and sustainable funding. Ethical dilemmas identified included the decision to continue nonbeneficial treatment, life-sustaining and life-prolonging therapies, and palliative sedation.
Anticipated outcomes for this study on IPC in Southern Minnesota will include suggestions to enhance patient care, improve organizational structures, and change policy, as indicated by the study findings. Understanding ethical dilemmas encountered by palliative care service providers and the complementary therapies used will identify new patient-centered care strategies.
There is currently an increased interest in IPC, an optimal approach to provide care for patients with chronic conditions and terminal illnesses . However, the literature indicates that there is no agreement on the definition of IPC’s essential components, and thus, there is the need to define its integral elements [ , ]. Consequently, IPC implementation varies across settings, and understanding its application is complicated. Describing and comparing different IPC systems such as the ones in Southern Minnesota and Osona offers greater insights into the implementation of IPC systems in 2 different countries.
The COVID-19 pandemic offers an opportunity for reflection and a new interpretation of health issues, especially in the ethical domain , such as resource provision and care prioritization [ ]. In addition, the pandemic has exposed unique health-related ethical dilemmas [ ], resulting in more complex decision-making processes [ ]. This study will reveal the ethical dilemmas Southern Minnesota palliative care providers have encountered during the COVID-19 pandemic and compare them to those confronted by health care professionals in Osona’s palliative care system.
In summary, further research on the implementation and evaluation of IPC systems is needed. Describing the essential elements, ethical dilemmas, and complementary therapies of the Southern Minnesota palliative care system will bring a greater understanding of their implementation within the IPC systems. Additionally, comparing 2 IPC systems that are similar in population and rural setting will provide a richer understanding of the impact of IPC systems on people with chronic illnesses. Study findings will contribute to enhanced patient care, organizational improvements, policy change, and a better understanding of the impact of different health care system models.
The research team would like to express their appreciation to Glen Taylor Nursing Institute for Family and Society for facilitating and supporting this collaboration.
Conflicts of Interest
Interview script.DOCX File , 22 KB
- Siouta N, van Beek K, Preston N, Hasselaar J, Hughes S, Payne S, et al. Towards integration of palliative care in patients with chronic heart failure and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a systematic literature review of European guidelines and pathways. BMC Palliat Care 2016 Feb 13;15(1):1-12 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Ewert B, Hodiamont F, van Wijngaarden J, Payne S, Groot M, Hasselaar J, et al. Building a taxonomy of integrated palliative care initiatives: results from a focus group. BMJ Support Palliat Care 2016 Mar 08;6(1):14-20 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Lyngsø AM, Godtfredsen NS, Høst D, Frølich A. Instruments to assess integrated care: a systematic review. Int J Integr Care 2014 Sep 25;14(3):1-15. [CrossRef]
- Garralda E, Hasselaar J, Carrasco JM, Van Beek K, Siouta N, Csikos A, et al. Integrated palliative care in the Spanish context: a systematic review of the literature. BMC Palliat Care 2016 May 13;15(1):49 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Palliative care. World Health Organization. 2018. URL: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/palliative-care [accessed 2019-01-30]
- Gómez-Batiste X, Martínez-Muñoz M, Blay C, Amblàs J, Vila L, Costa X, et al. Identifying patients with chronic conditions in need of palliative care in the general population: development of the NECPAL tool and preliminary prevalence rates in Catalonia. BMJ Support Palliat Care 2012;3(3):300-308. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- den Herder-van der Eerden M, Ewert B, Hodiamont F, Hesse M, Hasselaar J, Radbruch L. Towards accessible integrated palliative care. JICA 2017 Jul 03;25(3):222-232. [CrossRef]
- Kamal AH, Currow DC, Ritchie CS, Bull J, Abernethy AP. Community-based palliative care: the natural evolution for palliative care delivery in the U.S. J Pain Symptom Manage 2013;46(2):254-264 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Kallen MA, Yang D, Haas N. A technical solution to improving palliative and hospice care. Support Care Cancer 2012 Jan 16;20(1):167-174. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Engel PA, Spencer J, Paul T, Boardman JB. The geriatrics in primary care demonstration: integrating comprehensive geriatric care into the medical home: preliminary data. J Am Geriatr Soc 2016 Apr 21;64(4):875-879. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Building integrated palliative care programs and services. Càtedra de Cures Palliatives. Vic, Catalonia; 2017. URL: http://www.thewhpca.org/resources/category/building-integrated-palliative-care-programs-and-services [accessed 2021-06-03]
- Buss MK, Rock LK, McCarthy EP. Understanding palliative care and hospice: a review for primary care providers. Mayo Clin Proc 2017;92(2):280-286. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Boucher NA, Bull JH, Cross SH, Kirby C, Davis JK, Taylor DH. Patient, caregiver, and taxpayer knowledge of palliative care and views on a model of community-based palliative care. J Pain Symptom Manage 2018 Dec;56(6):951-956 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Singer SJ, Burgers J, Friedberg M, Rosenthal MB, Leape L, Schneider E. Defining and measuring integrated patient care: promoting the next frontier in health care delivery. Med Care Res Rev 2011;68(1):112-127. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Mondejar-Pont M, Ramon-Aribau A, Gómez-Batiste X. Integrated palliative care definition and constitutive elements: scoping review. JICA 2019 Oct 10;27(4):285-304. [CrossRef]
- Sherrell Z. Medicare and palliative care: what to know. Medical News Today. 2020 Nov 13. URL: https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/does-medicare-cover-palliative-care [accessed 2021-08-10]
- How does medicare help with serious illness care? CaringInfo. 2021. URL: https://www.caringinfo.org/planning/financial-matters/medicare/ [accessed 2021-08-10]
- Hospice care Coverage. Medicare. 2021. URL: https://www.medicare.gov/coverage/hospice-care [accessed 2021-08-10]
- Centeno C, Arnillas P, Hernansanz S, Flores LA, Gómez M, López-Lara F. The reality of palliative care in Spain. Palliat Med 2000 Sep 01;14(5):387-394. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Doldi M, Moscatelli A, Ravelli A, Spiazzi R, Petralia P. Medicine and humanism in the time of COVID-19. Ethical choices. Acta Biomed 2020 Nov 10;91(4):1-10 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Blot F, Dumont SN, Vigouret-Viant L, Verotte N, Rossignol J, Rieutord A, et al. Ethical issues related to the COVID-19 pandemic in patients with cancer: experience and organisations in a French comprehensive cancer centre. BMJ Support Palliat Care 2020 Aug 27:1-8. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Bolt SR, van der Steen JT, Mujezinović I, Janssen DJ, Schols JM, Zwakhalen SM, et al. Practical nursing recommendations for palliative care for people with dementia living in long-term care facilities during the COVID-19 pandemic: A rapid scoping review. Int J Nurs Stud 2021 Jan;113:103781 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Han JJ, Luc JG, Pak E. Ethical dilemmas associated with the COVID-19 pandemic: dealing with the unknowns and unanswerables during training. J Am Coll Cardiol 2020 Sep 08;76(10):1266-1269 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Robert R, Kentish-Barnes N, Boyer A, Laurent A, Azoulay E, Reignier J. Ethical dilemmas due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Ann Intensive Care 2020 Jun 17;10(1):84 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Dahlin CM. National consensus project for quality palliative care: assuring quality palliative care through clinical practice guidelines. In: Oxford Textbook of Palliative Nursing (5th ed). Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2018.
- Adler SR, Marchand LR, Heap N. Integrative palliative care: enhancing the natural synergy between integrative health and palliative medicine. J Altern Complement Med 2019;25(3):257-259. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Zeng YS, Wang C, Ward KE, Hume AL. Complementary and alternative medicine in hospice and palliative care: a systematic review. J Pain Symptom Manage 2018;56(5):781-794 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Yin RK. Case Study Research: Design and Method (second edition). New York: Sage; 1994.
- Defining rural population. US Health Resources and Services Administration. Defining Rural Populations. 2021. URL: https://www.hrsa.gov/rural-health/about-us/definition/index.html [accessed 2021-08-10]
- Official statistics of Catalunya. Gencat. 2020. URL: https://www.idescat.cat/?lang=en [accessed 2021-07-15]
- Minnesota Counties by population. Minnesota Demographics. Census redistricting data. 2020. URL: https://www.minnesota-demographics.com/counties_by_population [accessed 2021-01-09]
- Servei Català de la Salut. Mòduls de seguiment d’indicadors de qualitat. https://msiq.catsalut.cat/index.html [accessed 2019-07-23].
- It’s time to face aging, Minnesota. FaceAging MN. 2021. URL: https://faceagingmn.org/minnesota-population-aging-map/ [accessed 2021-12-28]
- Symens Smith A, Trevelyan E. Older population in rural America. United States Census Bureau. 2019 Oct 22. URL: https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2019/10/older-population-in-rural-america.html [accessed 2021-08-10]
- Assarroudi A, Heshmati Nabavi F, Armat MR, Ebadi A, Vaismoradi M. Directed qualitative content analysis: the description and elaboration of its underpinning methods and data analysis process. J Res Nurs 2018 Feb 10;23(1):42-55 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Bainbridge D, Brazil K, Krueger P, Ploeg J, Taniguchi A, Darnay J. Evaluating program integration and the rise in collaboration: case study of a palliative care network. J Palliat Care 2018 Dec 19;27(4):270-278.
- van der Eerden M, Csikos A, Busa C, Hughes S, Radbruch L, Menten J, et al. Experiences of patients, family and professional caregivers with Integrated Palliative Care in Europe: protocol for an international, multicenter, prospective, mixed method study. BMC Palliat Care 2014 Nov 21;13(1):1-9. [CrossRef]
- Tan WS, Lee A, Yang SY, Chan S, Wu HY, Ng CWL, et al. Integrating palliative care across settings: a retrospective cohort study of a hospice home care programme for cancer patients. Palliat Med 2016 Jul 11;30(7):634-641. [CrossRef] [Medline]
- Chamsi-Pasha H, Chamsi-Pasha M, Albar M. Ethical dilemmas in the era of COVID-19. Avicenna J Med 2020;10(3):102-105 [FREE Full text] [CrossRef] [Medline]
|IPC: integrated palliative care|
Edited by T Leung; submitted 29.12.21; peer-reviewed by JS Berner, M Mars; comments to author 29.03.22; revised version received 19.04.22; accepted 17.05.22; published 01.07.22Copyright
©Meritxell Mondejar-Pont, Kristen Abbott-Anderson, Anna Ramon-Aribau, Renee Kumpula, Tammy Neiman, Hans-Peter De Ruiter. Originally published in JMIR Research Protocols (https://www.researchprotocols.org), 01.07.2022.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR Research Protocols, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on https://www.researchprotocols.org, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.